“Coltzilla Dead” Pronouncements Premature
It has come to our attention that one of our colleagues in the Colts blogosphere has taken shots at Coltzilla regarding a lack of steady content recently. In fact, in the latest comment, it was suggested that Coltzilla is “dead.” As the site’s founder and editor I think it is worthwhile to address any of our readers’ concerns about the current and future health of Coltzilla.
Our readers should know that Coltzilla upholds a standard of reporting and analysis that we hope best serves Colts fans. We do not engage in long-winded or repetitive rants regarding rather mundane occurrences in the Colts front office, draft strategies, private practices, or minor surgeries to players.
When Coltzilla covers injuries, we only do so when trustworthy and verifiable sources report that injuries have occurred, and our injury expert Laura Calaway does considerable research to analyze the current and future impacts of that injury on the effected player. Laura’s work is very professional and receives resounding support from our readers and from others in the blogging community.
Coltzilla does not, on the other hand, attempt to create news and controversy, or attempt to shock the Colts community when there is, quite simply, very little of substance to report.
Unlike some more established blogs on the internet, our writers do not get paychecks, which means we all work very hard to generate professional stories without promise of any meaningful compensation. Accordingly, during times like a long NFL lockout and an extended legal proceeding whereby no football is actually happening, our staff has the ability to take some much needed r and r, focus on their jobs, take vacations, and allow creative ideas to form for the coming season.
It is understandable that some blogs and sources for news about the Colts have different motivations. Some sources may feel that multiple stories covering the birth of Peyton Manning’s twins, and discussing the reasons why “hiding” the news is not within the proper rights of professional football players because they get paid high salaries or because they shoot a lot of commercials is an example of upholding positive writing principles and standards.
Some blogs might find it worthwhile to set out on a mission to expose the Colts organization as unfriendly to the media, secretive, and defending the media’s right to have access to whatever they please. Coltzilla has no such motivations, and adheres to a policy whereby the likelihood of access to the team increases significantly when blogs do not attempt to burn, harshly and unjustly criticize, attack, or misrepresent its players, coaches, administrative staff, or owner.
Do not misread the above to suggest that Coltzilla is unwilling to be critical of any aspect of the team. On the contrary, we work hard to write stories that look at team performance — including players, coaches, and administrative staff — in as objective a way as possible, a quick review of Check it to Pancakes podcasts will illustrate this point.
Writer Jacob Crocker has spent hours of his own time compiling a very detailed and comprehensive set of traditional and advanced statistics. In fact, he is currently trying to reform, improve, and clean up the 2010 statistics — as well as trying to perfect his process for future years.
Even after the season ended we have made efforts to add to our writing staff, to bring in more voices and perspectives, and try to present analysis that all Colts fans can relate to and respect. Some perspectives will be more palatable than others, but we feel it is our job to be thorough.
Writer Greg Cowan has rejoined the team and will pick up where he left off in 2011, presenting a witty and humorous writing style that our readers enjoy. Writer Anthony Payne delivers a no holds barred approach to issues that effect the NFL and the way football fans view their favorite sport. Writer Justin Javan has spent time developing a readership on Facebook and has presented new concepts and ideas to make future Coltzilla content more interactive and illustrative.
TJ Higley has been an extremely reliable writer who covers game reviews from the previous seasons — including photos from the game — power rankings posts, and offers local television coverage of the Colts to fans who do not have the luxury of living within the Indianapolis television market.
Since the season ended, Coltzilla has added new features, such as the statistics and draft pages. During the off-season, unlike other Colts blogs who may attempt to cover training camp and summer activities from afar, our staff makes it a point to have a presence at training camp practices.
In short, a dearth of stories during the slowest period of time in any football season, particularly during a lockout of players keeping actual football from happening, is not cause for alarm. None of the Coltzilla staff intends to let this site whither or falter. We will continue working hard to provide quality content and any suggestions that the site is dead or dying are both premature and inaccurate.
We appreciate your continued support.
Print article | This entry was posted by Brett Mock on May 30, 2011 at 1:08 am, and is filed under Off-Season Coverage. Follow any responses to this post through . You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed. |
Yeah well, maybe you just aren’t a ‘real Colts blog’. Whatever that means.
Hang with ‘em. The comments about you guys were asinine and totally out of place.
Thank you for the support Nate.
Your article was spot on, I was so glad to see a response to that garbage over at SB. Thank you, that needed to be done. Coltzilla and 18to88, Go Colts!!!
I’m so very glad that this was written. As one of the Stampede Blue “exiles” circa the latest wave of banishment that happened a few months ago, I check the site (SB) every now and again to look at the fanposts section. I did catch the “Coltzilla is dead” comment however and wished I still had an account so I could link BBS to the numerous articles posted in the timeframe in which he claimed the site was dead. It’s just another cheap shot from another cheap “writer”… it’s like someone gave a 12 year old Patriots fan the keys to a Colt’s website. Truly sad.
I’ve always loved the writers/articles on this site however and finally decided to get an account to join in on the conversation. Keep up the good work, cheers!
Thanks so much for the support. We appreciate it!
B-b-but TEH PAGE HITZ!!!
/No need to make up new when there are no news. Good job guys.
I removed the SB website from my favorites and e-mailed SBNation to have the editor of that blog replaced by an actual Colts fan. Keep up the great work. I love your blog.
Good Choice! SB will probably replace BigBlueShoe with an equivalent idoit. I’ve gotten kicked off the website by BigBlueShoe cuz I can’t seem to be able to write an honest reply to his idoicracy with out calling him out. A good colts site should be about the colts and football, not his ego and rants. Thats why I like Coltzilla.
I’m sorry, I never comment over here. But it’s very nice to have a bit of optimism in an article. I can always count on you guys coming through for me. And yeah, thanks for not making up news or turning an article about how great it is that Collie’s feeling 100% into a whine-fest about the Colts media silence.
GO HORSE!
So, seeing as how you still have an account on SB… you should convince many others to visit this site instead for Colts discussion. Maybe we could get enough people over here to put the squeeze on Brad’s precious page hitz. Not to mention, the articles are immeasurably more even-keeled and factually correct. Win-win!
Great retort Brett, only problem is that you linked to a raw sewage dump in the first paragraph. Recommend you either remove it entirely or replace it with a screenshot. Why give that weasel any more page views?
I understand the sentiment but the way I see it, if we’re going to directly respond to an article it is only “proper” to link to the article we’re responding to. We would want others to do the same for us, so I try to follow a “treat others as you would like to be treated” philosophy.
Luckily, there is rarely a need for any kind of direct response to anything on other blogs, as we are all trying to do the same work and as much as we would all like to break stories, most of us realize that creating legitimate news without access is supremely difficult. I appreciate the support though
A couple of visits to BigBlueShoe’s rants will detour all the great Colts fans right back to coltzilla’s great articles. Bigblueshoe’s rants are the best advertising for coltzilla I would say.
I check this site multiple times a day for all of the reasons you just listed. I felt guilty clicking on your link to SB because I haven’t been there in months. There’s nothing there for any self-respecting fan. Keep on setting the standard.
This article is hysterical. I think that other blog is a joke and suited for readers who enjoy the national enquirer and other questionable publications. Only two Colts blogs I follow regularly, both authors have posted on this wall.
Who am I? : I made a vague assertion that a 35 year old professional football player had some kind of injury during the season and recent reports proved I was right! Whether or not it was actually related to my behavioral observations is irrelevant. I’m so awesome…
I am admittedly a bit confused by your post but thank you for visiting and posting.
They said all season that Manning was hurt and that is why he played poorly. They then wrote a story congratulating themselves for being right all season.
That is, when the story of his surgery surfaced.
Agreed. I personally find the connection between the two tenuous at best, but that is just my opinion. In short, if you have a theory first, you tend to read the evidence in a way that supports it. When you look at the evidence and then reach a conclusion, the assertion in September is scarcely related to the surgery — if at all.
When I (rarely) go to the StampedeBlue website, as soon as I see the article is written by BBS I move on. I was also exiled from the site, which I find hilarious. He obviously tries to inflame readers to increase his page views, but bans those who disagree with him. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense for your advertisers, prevent the audience from seeing their ads!
Keep up the good work Brett, between you and 18to88, I can always count on mature, informative discussions.
Keep up the good work. If I was SB I would hope that you were dead too. Then I could have all teh page hitz!!!
Seriously though, kudos for not making up news.
Thank you for posting this. When I first joined SB, I thought it was a great site for Colts new, updates, etc., but now it reads like a supermarket tabloid. I personally think that BBS is a hypocrite. He demeans his readers’ opinions but is quick to ban readers who negatively say something about him or don’t agree with him. He calls Bill Polian a tyrant but tyranny is how SB is run; basically it’s his way or the highway. Banning good contributors like JesusNinja is a prime example. That blog has been going downhill for a while. It’s refreshing to see that you can refute another person’s opinion without resorting to childish name-calling or threats of being banned. I look forward to being part of what looks to be a great Colts site.
The comments at SB nowadays are golden. It is hilarious. I went back to see how people were doing a few days ago. I read some of the comments and now I’m hooked. It’s my daily dose of laughter.
I love this site. I don’t need up to the minute BS of constant posts with no substance. Quality not quantity. The news will flow soon when the lockout is over. Your site is quality.
Thanks very much Jules
Jake and Brett, it is called quiet strength. I guess BBS doesn’t get it.
Jake, loved the OL stats that you e-mailed me a month or two ago, great compilation. Keep up the good work.
Now, if you can compile something for the DL and LBs, that would be great. I would really like to know how our Pro Bowl DEs Mathis and Freeney grade on the run D front. Just a thought.
i am also one of the recent exiles of blue stampede/bbs whiner site. I have also written to sb nation asking for a true fan to replace the poser that runs the bbs whiner site. He is a rumor mongerer who only worries about “hits”. I appreciate your arcticle and promise to visit more. Thanks again.
Well said. Very well said. I show my support with page hits. Coltzilla gets some, 18to88 gets some…and that’s about it.